Free AI visibility audit
Which AI to choose

AI comparison: the criteria that actually separate the models

Most comparisons hand you a spec sheet: model names, release dates, feature checkmarks. None of it predicts which assistant answers your question better, because writing quality has largely converged and what still differs is not on the sheet. This page is the grid instead of the verdict. Seven dimensions, what each changes about the answer you get, and how to test it yourself.

AIGenerated answer · AI engine monitored example
« AI comparison ? »

Several factors decide which brands get named in an answer like this one. Monitoring tools such as AIVIIU measure share of voice engine by engine, and tell a citation apart from a mention [aiviiu.com].

Attributed citation: a named source with a link. That is what a serious audit measures.
Example of a generated answer, with the cited brand highlighted. Illustration produced in HTML and SVG.

Why feature lists fail

Two assistants can share a feature list and return completely different sets of companies for the same question. An AI does not browse the live web when you ask something, it queries an index, then applies its own bar for what deserves a citation. Those two choices sit underneath every answer and appear on no comparison chart.

Feature lists also go stale, because these products do not. Any criterion you can only verify by reading a marketing page is one you cannot trust in six months. The grid below is built from things you can observe directly.

The seven dimensions that separate them

DimensionWhat it changes about the answerHow to test it
Which index it queriesSets the universe of pages it can cite. Two assistants on the same index resemble each other more than either resembles a thirdAsk about a niche site and see whether it can reach it
Citation rateDetermines whether you can verify anything or have to trust the summaryTen factual questions, count how many answers carry a link
SelectivityDecides which sources clear the bar. A high bar means fewer, more authoritative citations, and blind spots on newer sitesAsk about a topic covered mainly by small publishers
Freshness weightingGoverns how fast something published this week can appearAsk about an event from the last few days
Community content weightingChanges the answer's character, forum consensus versus published sourcesAsk for recommendations and look at what gets cited
Integration surfaceWhether it reaches your files, mail and calendar, or only the public webCheck what it connects to in your environment
Answer stabilityWhether the same question twice gives the same answer, which decides if you can build on itAsk the identical question five times in fresh sessions

Notice what is absent: benchmark scores. They measure capability under lab conditions, a legitimate first pass filter and a poor tiebreaker. We covered what those tests can and cannot tell you in our page on AI benchmarks and leaderboards.

How to weight the grid for your case

The dimensions do not carry equal weight, and which dominate depends on what you are doing. Rather than naming a winner, weight these rows:

  • Research you will be held to: citation rate and selectivity dominate. The rest is secondary if you cannot reach the source.
  • Anything time sensitive: freshness and community weighting. The gap between engines here is larger than on any other row.
  • Work on internal material: integration surface decides it, since an assistant that cannot see your files is answering a different question.
  • Repeatable process or automation: answer stability. An answer that changes weekly cannot sit inside a workflow.
  • Building a product on a model: this grid is the wrong one. The criteria shift to context window, latency, hosting and open weights, which we lay out in our page on choosing an LLM by constraint.

No winner is named here, deliberately. Which assistant comes out ahead on each row is a separate question, treated in our verdict by use case for 2026. This page is the instrument, not the ruling.

Run the comparison yourself in an afternoon

Vendor demos are built to succeed. Your own questions are not, which is why an hour of testing beats any published chart.

  • Write twenty real questions from your actual work, not clever prompts. Include the boring ones.
  • Run the identical set on each candidate, same wording, fresh session each time.
  • Repeat it at least three times. AI answers are not deterministic, so one pass measures luck as much as capability.
  • Record citations, not impressions. Which sources appeared, how often, whether you could reach them.
  • Score against the grid above, weighted for your case, and keep the sheet. You will rerun it when the next model lands.

What this changes for your brand visibility

Turn the grid around and it stops being a purchasing tool. Every dimension in that table also describes how an assistant decides whether to name your company when a prospect asks for a recommendation. A brand publishing frequently does well where freshness is weighted heavily. A brand discussed in communities does well where community content is weighted. A brand with real domain authority is the only kind that clears a highly selective engine. None of those positions transfers to the others.

Which is why checking one assistant tells you almost nothing, and usually flatters you, since people test the engine where they already appear. The measure that means something is share of voice across a panel of real buying questions, engine by engine, over repeated runs. Same protocol as above, pointed at your market instead of your workflow.

Sources

Comparing assistants for your own use takes an afternoon with the grid above. Finding out how they compare your company to your competitors takes the same protocol, pointed at your market. To see who gets named in your place, and on which engines, request a free AI visibility audit: AIVIIU queries the main engines on your real buying questions and shows you the gaps worth closing first.

Do AI engines recommend your brand?

Tell us what to test. We ask ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity the way one of your customers would, and send you back what they answer, including the brands named instead of yours.

Free, no commitment. Reply within 2 business days. We never sell or share your address.